When you have spent decades building a 401(k), IRA, pension or other retirement savings, few things are more frightening than a creditor or debt collector suggesting that everything you worked for could be taken away. For someone approaching retirement or already living on retirement income, the threat can be especially powerful. A collection call about an old credit card, medical bill or personal loan can quickly turn into fear about losing the money you need for the rest of your life.
Before withdrawing retirement money to satisfy a creditor, however, it is important to understand what a creditor can actually do under the law. Many retirement assets receive significant legal protection, and Illinois provides a broad exemption for qualifying retirement plans. In some situations, taking money out of a protected retirement account to pay unsecured debt can turn protected money into money that is much easier for creditors to reach.
There is another reason to slow down before moving any money. Not everyone claiming to collect a debt is legitimate. Scammers increasingly use the same fear and urgency associated with genuine financial problems to persuade people to withdraw savings, transfer money or provide access to their accounts. Older adults can be particularly attractive targets because criminals know that someone who has worked for decades may have accumulated retirement savings.
Are Retirement Accounts Protected From Creditors in Illinois?
Illinois law provides significant protection for retirement assets. Under Section 12-1006 of the Illinois Code of Civil Procedure, a debtor’s interest in qualifying retirement plans is generally exempt from judgment, attachment, execution and seizure for the satisfaction of debts. Depending on the account and circumstances, federal law can provide additional protections.
That does not mean every dollar associated with retirement is automatically untouchable in every situation. The type of account matters. How the account was established can matter. Whether money remains inside a protected retirement plan or has already been distributed can also make a difference. Certain obligations may be treated differently under state or federal law.
The important point is that someone should not assume that a credit card company, collection agency or other unsecured creditor can simply take a 401(k), IRA or pension because a debt remains unpaid.
Watch Our Videos on the Chicago Bankruptcy YouTube Channel
Be Very Careful About Cashing Out Retirement Savings to Pay Debt
One of the biggest financial mistakes a person with serious debt can make is acting out of fear before understanding what assets are protected.
Imagine someone has accumulated substantial credit card debt but also has money in a legally protected retirement account. Collection calls begin, and the person becomes frightened that the creditor is coming after everything. To make the problem go away, the person withdraws money from the retirement account and uses it to pay the credit cards.
That decision may create several problems. The person has depleted money intended to support retirement, may face tax consequences depending on the withdrawal, and may have used a legally protected asset to pay a debt that potentially could have been addressed through bankruptcy or another legal strategy.
Once retirement savings have been withdrawn and mixed with ordinary money in a checking or savings account, the legal analysis can also become more complicated.
Before liquidating retirement assets to pay unsecured debt, it can therefore make sense to speak with a bankruptcy attorney and determine what property is protected and what alternatives are available.
Debt Collectors Cannot Simply Threaten Anything They Want
Having a legitimate debt does not eliminate your consumer rights.
Federal law prohibits debt collectors covered by the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act from using abusive, unfair or deceptive practices. A collector cannot falsely claim that you will be arrested for failing to pay an ordinary consumer debt. A collector also cannot threaten to seize wages, bank accounts or property when the threatened action cannot legally be taken or when the collector has no intention of taking it.
A legitimate creditor may have legal remedies. Depending on the circumstances, a creditor may sue, obtain a judgment and pursue property that is legally available for collection. That is very different from a caller suggesting that payment must be made immediately or that all of your property is automatically at risk.
If a collector’s threat causes you to consider withdrawing retirement savings, selling property or borrowing money simply to make the caller go away, that is precisely the point at which slowing down and obtaining legal advice may be valuable.
Is It Really a Debt Collector, or Is It a Scam?
Consumers also need to distinguish aggressive debt collection from outright fraud.
A scammer may already know your name, address, age, relatives or pieces of your financial history. That information can make a fraudulent call sound surprisingly convincing. Caller ID can also be manipulated, and criminals may impersonate businesses, financial institutions and government agencies.
The Federal Trade Commission recommends verifying a debt before paying it. A legitimate debt collector generally must provide validation information identifying the collector, creditor and amount allegedly owed, along with information about your debt-collection rights.
Be suspicious when someone demands immediate payment while discouraging you from hanging up, checking the debt or speaking with someone you trust. Threats of arrest, demands for secrecy and instructions to move money to supposedly “protect” it are major warning signs.
Never provide banking credentials, retirement-account passwords, Social Security information or other sensitive financial information merely because an unexpected caller appears to know something about you.
Older Adults and Retirees Are Particularly Attractive Targets
Scams involving retirement savings deserve special attention for older adults and their families.
The Federal Trade Commission has documented a sharp increase in large-dollar losses among adults age 60 and older from scammers impersonating businesses and government agencies. Some victims have been persuaded to empty bank accounts or withdraw retirement savings because a scammer convinced them that their money was in danger.
The psychology is deliberate. The caller creates a crisis and then offers the solution. Your identity has supposedly been stolen. Your Social Security number is allegedly connected to a crime. Your bank account is supposedly compromised. A debt must allegedly be paid today. Your savings supposedly need to be transferred somewhere “safe.”
The manufactured emergency is designed to prevent the victim from having time to think.
If someone unexpectedly tells you to withdraw retirement money, transfer savings, buy cryptocurrency or gift cards, hand over cash or move money into a different account for its “protection,” stop the transaction and independently verify what is happening.
Family members can help older relatives by establishing a simple rule: before transferring a large amount of money in response to an unexpected telephone call, email, text message or computer warning, call a trusted family member or adviser first.
Social Security Benefits Have Protections Too
Many retirees are also concerned about whether debt collectors can take Social Security benefits.
Federal protections apply to Social Security and certain other federal benefits. When protected federal benefits are received through direct deposit, banks generally must automatically protect up to two months’ worth of qualifying benefits when they receive a garnishment order. Additional exemptions may also apply.
There are important exceptions and special rules, including certain government debts and family-support obligations, so Social Security should not simply be treated as immune from every possible collection action. But an ordinary debt collector cannot call a retiree and simply order the person’s Social Security money turned over.
What Should You Do When a Collector Threatens Your Savings?
First, do not panic and do not make a major financial decision during the telephone call. Ask who is calling, what company they represent, who the original creditor is and how much they claim you owe. Obtain the required validation information and independently verify the company rather than relying exclusively on a phone number or link supplied by the caller.
Keep copies of letters, emails and text messages and document telephone calls. Never ignore genuine court papers or a lawsuit because legitimate creditors can use the court system to enforce valid debts.
At the same time, do not assume that a threatening voice on the telephone has accurately described the law.
Most importantly, consider getting legal advice before withdrawing money from a retirement account to deal with substantial unsecured debt. A bankruptcy attorney can review the debt, the type of retirement account involved, other assets and income, pending collection activity and whether bankruptcy could provide a better way to address the problem.
Bankruptcy May Protect What You Have Spent a Lifetime Building
Bankruptcy is sometimes viewed only as a way to eliminate debt. For people who have accumulated assets, however, an equally important part of bankruptcy planning is understanding what property the law allows them to protect.
Someone with overwhelming credit card, medical or personal-loan debt may be in a very different financial position than that collection balance suggests if much of the person’s wealth consists of legally protected retirement assets.
That is why the order in which financial decisions are made matters.
Before draining a 401(k), IRA or other retirement account to satisfy creditors, find out whether that money is protected and whether the underlying debt can be addressed another way. Once retirement savings accumulated over decades are gone, rebuilding them may be difficult or impossible.
Talk to a Chicago Bankruptcy Attorney Before Using Retirement Money to Pay Debt
If creditors are pursuing you and you are worried about your retirement savings, Joseph Wrobel, Ltd. can review your financial circumstances and explain how Illinois and federal bankruptcy laws may apply to your assets and debts.
The goal is not simply to stop collection calls. It is to understand which assets may be protected, which debts must be addressed and what legal options may allow you to regain financial stability without unnecessarily sacrificing the savings you worked years to build.
Before allowing a collector’s threats to dictate your next financial move, learn what the law actually allows. Call us at 312-781-0996 or email Josephwrobel@Chicagobankruptcy.com.